Qatar's death row and the invisible migrant workforce deemed unworthy of due process
19/01/2023, 10:36
In Anil’s case, the embassy in Doha asked for 30,000 Riyals from the Nepali government to pay a lawyer
to defend him at the Supreme Court. However, this request was bounced back and forth between the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs to the Ministry of Labour who then sent it to the Foreign Employment Board,
wasting precious time. As Neha Choudhary at the International Labour Organisation (ILO) in Nepal told
us, there is also a “disjunct” between the various government institutions in Nepal responsible for
labourers working abroad. She said:
If there was enhanced coordination between various ministries, particularly the Ministry of
Labour and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, as well as all three tiers of government, a lot of the
gaps in ensuring rights of migrant workers could be addressed.
The Nepali Foreign Employment Board manages a fund of 6 billion rupees (£38 million), to be used for
the assistance of migrant workers where required. This fund is financed by the migrant workers
themselves, who are required to contribute as a condition of their foreign employment permit from
Nepal.
Read more: World Cup 2022: what the dream of football success means to migrants
Guidelines, which came out in 2021, provide that the Board can spend 1.5 million rupees (around
£9,500) to hire a lawyer for a worker detained abroad. However, one of our sources reported to us that
the Foreign Employment Board had told them they had helped fewer than four such prisoners in this
way in three years.
Other NGOs told us that the embassies argue they are understaffed and underfunded as well as poorly
coordinated. Deepika Thapaliya, of Equidem, explained that the effectiveness of diplomatic
interventions on behalf of the foreign national depended on the “bargaining power” of the foreign
government, which many South Asian states do not have in the Gulf because they are so reliant on
remittances (payments sent home by migrant workers to support their families in their home states).
Nepal, for example, derives a quarter of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) from remittances.
Similarly, Human Rights Watch and Justice Project Pakistan found that Pakistani migrant workers in
Saudi Arabia did not seek consular assistance when faced with criminal charges, “because they did not
believe Pakistani officials would offer any assistance, and they did not want to waste limited money on
such phone calls”.
https://theconversation.com/qatars-death-row-and-the-invisible-migrant-workforce-deemed-unworthy-of-due-process-191017
Page 5 of 12